Is a $17 Slice of Pie at Disney World Worth the Splurge? We Tried It, and the Answer Might Surprise You!
Disney World is a place of magic, but it’s also a place where your wallet can take a hit—especially when it comes to food. One of our favorite spots, The Cake Bake Shop Bakery (https://allears.net/dining/location/the-cake-bake-shop-by-gwendolyn-rogers/), is a glittering oasis of decadent treats, but it’s not without its controversies. With cake slices priced at $22 and pie slices at $17, it’s a destination that demands a second thought. But here’s where it gets controversial: is the experience truly worth the price tag? We put their new Blueberry Crumble Pie to the test, and the results were... well, let’s just say it’s complicated.
Located at Disney’s BoardWalk resort (https://allears.net/walt-disney-world/wdw-planning/disneys-boardwalk-and-the-epcot-resort-area/), this bakery is a feast for the eyes. The Blueberry Crumble Pie ($17) is a showstopper, featuring a signature all-butter pie crust packed with juicy blueberries, lemon zest, and sugar, all topped with a light brown sugar crumble. Sounds irresistible, right? But this is the part most people miss: the experience isn’t as seamless as you’d expect for the price.
When we ordered the pie, it arrived in the bakery’s iconic white box, wrapped in parchment paper. Sounds perfect, until the blueberry juice started leaking everywhere. We had to dash to the BoardWalk Deli next door for a plate to avoid a sticky disaster. Pro tip: grab extra napkins while you’re there, because the bakery’s silverware is pre-packaged, making it tricky to snag extras.
Now, let’s talk taste. The blueberry filling? Absolutely divine. It’s bursting with flavor, and the whole blueberries add a delightful texture. The crust is soft, buttery, and pairs perfectly with the filling. The crumble topping? A sweet, crumbly masterpiece that’s neither dry nor overly dense. It’s a slice of pie that’s hard to forget.
But here’s the million-dollar question: Is it worth $17? Our team was split. On one hand, it’s a high-quality, indulgent dessert that’s perfect for blueberry lovers. On the other, the messy packaging and lack of convenience left us wondering if the experience matched the price. For a premium treat, we expected a premium experience—and this fell just short.
If you’re willing to splurge and don’t mind a little mess, the Blueberry Crumble Pie is a must-try. But if you’re on the fence, it might leave you questioning whether the magic of Disney justifies the cost. And this is the part that’ll spark debate: Is Disney pricing justified when the experience doesn’t always match the hype?
You can find this pie at The Cake Bake Shop Bakery at Disney’s BoardWalk resort. And while you’re at it, check out our review of Disney Springs’ newest treats (https://allears.net/2026/01/23/review-new-snacks-just-hit-disney-springs-and-youre-gonna-love-them/) for more sweet adventures.
What’s your take on The Cake Bake Shop Bakery? Is $17 too much for a slice of pie, or is it a justified indulgence? Let us know in the comments—we’re eager to hear your thoughts!
